Revision as of 09:42, 5 September 2005

tcm: sorry, but how about my awesomely snazzy Ikulu's List page? huh? huh!?

Yes, you did a good job dressing up my idea. Good work, carry on! So move it back into Rumors and Leads where it belongs. --ET 00:24, 8 May 2005 (EDT)

tcm: what? that shit is too important to leave at the bottom of some Rumors page. it should stay on the front page, mos def.

Durrr, you can put it at the top of the Rumors and Leads page. It's a goddamned LEAD. You're screwing up the organization of the wiki. If you were doing a comic book encyclopedia, the X-Men would still be listed near the end under X, no matter how important you think they are. --ET 00:38, 8 May 2005 (EDT)

tcm: yeah, but no. pages that have links to other pages that are of the same kind stay on the front page. the organization is not being screwed up; you're just being paranoid.

I do not think it means what you think it means. Why don't you learn about paranoia before you start diagnosing it. Everything else is a major category - Ikulu's List is the only thing that clearly belongs within one of the other items on the list. --ET 00:57, 8 May 2005 (EDT)

thecomicman says:Ikulu's List isn't just a freaking lead. it's the goddamn roadmap for the forseeable future. this is what we're supposed to be looking for. it's too important not to be on the front page.

Moving discussion to where it belongs... --ET 07:27, 10 May 2005 (EDT)

If the Main Page should have the most important things in the campaign, then shouldn't the entry for the Octopus Gods be here all the time? They are, after all, not just a "roadmap" but the entire freaking point of the game. Your logic doesn't hold. It wasn't like Ikulu's List even existed until I created the page. It was so important that the page didn't exist until a month after the wiki was created and now you think it has to be on the Main Page. But hey - let's go to a vote. Everyone - please cast a vote on whether Ikulu's List belongs on the Main Page. --ET 07:27, 10 May 2005 (EDT)

Maggie says: I'm voting no. No matter how important, it's only part of information we have (and from what I gather, not confirmed), not an organizational piece of it. Adding a note: I will oblige with the wishes of the majority regarding Ikulu's List on the homepage - I have protected the page for now from further changes.

* * *

The newest list seems to exclude the Skin of Amphisbaen which is present on the two other lists. What do you make of that?

Furthermore, it raises a more obvious question: if Alexander successfully gathered all the ingredients, what went wrong? Why wasn't the book used and the spell cast? --Noah 12:40, 5 Sep 2005 (EDT)